Social Media

back

International School or ESF? Sassy Mama Ruth Benny answers reader questions

ExpertsPost Category - ExpertsExperts
LearnPost Category - LearnLearn - Post Category - SchoolsSchools

I am currently 37 week pregnant, and beginning to think about education options for my son, but am unsure whether International School or ESF would be a better choice. What are the advantages and disadvantages of International Schools versus ESF?

Parents often ask about the difference between an ESF school and an International School at primary level.

Here are a few differences to note:

ESFInternational/Private
Partially government funded and partially funded by fees (until 2016)Mostly funded by fees
Catchment area system – apply to only ONE ESF school based on your home addressNo geographical restrictions; can apply to a school near or far from home, and as many as you like.
Fully accredited to offer IB curriculumFree to run any curriculum, or a mix of curricula
Less competitivePopular schools fiercely competitive
Class size large at 30Class sizes vary between 11 and 28

Let’s consider how ESF compares to the alternatives at three stages: preschool, primary and secondary.

Preschool
ESF operates four – soon to be five – kindergartens under its affiliated company, ESF Educational Services Limited. Previously, students at these kindergartens earned priority when being considered for a place at primary. This priority has been abolished starting with selections for the AY 2014/15.

International kindergartens are numerous. They run various curricula, adopt various approaches and vary in their selection criteria and process. Some are more reputable than others. One of the very best tools in selecting a kindergarten is to analyse their graduation statistics. If the kindergarten has a good track record in having their students accepted by the primary schools you’re interested in, this would be worth considering seriously. ESF kindergartens don’t share this data and, even if they did, it will take quite a few years for any patterns to emerge under the new policy.

So, why choose an ESF kindergarten?

Judge an ESF kindergarten using the same criteria you’d use to judge any other kindergarten. Some plus points for ESF include the established brand name and reputation, based on excellent teaching staff and a solid curriculum and fully accredited by IBO.

Primary
ESF’s nine Primary schools start at Year 1 (age five). Parents can apply to only one school, based on their home address.

All schools are similar in that they follow the PYP curriculum and cost $70,000 per year (AY 2013/14). Otherwise, ESF schools vary in size, diversity and culture.

International schools vary wildly. Very few are charging fees as low as ESF.

Secondary
Under normal circumstances, a student graduating from an ESF primary school is offered a place in the secondary school of their catchment area. ESF operates only five secondary schools.

All schools offer IB MYP and IB DP – either UK GCSEs or International GCSE. As an alternative to the IB DP, BTec is also offered for students preferring a more practical approach to learning.

ESF’s IB DP results are impressive: In 2013, 98.4% of candidates passed the IB Diploma with an average score of 34.7 points (out of 45).

Cost, Competition & Catchment.
A few final words on three areas:

Cost: Without a doubt, ESF schools provide a high quality education for a lot less than other schools, made possible by government funding. The trade-off, however, is the large class size. All this is bound to change in 2016/17 when the government will no longer be subsidising ESF students. For more information on these changes, see this article.

Competition: At ESF schools, the competition is not nearly as intense as it is at some other top international schools. Roughly 2.1 applications are received for every available place. This ratio is up to 10:1 in some other schools. ESF schools do select students to some extent, but the process is not too rigourous. That said, it’s risky to apply to one ESF school without any back-ups.

Catchment: The catchment area system means that parents don’t have flexibility to choose the school they prefer. Applications are received only from eligible students with proof of address within the catchment area. If the student moves outside the catchment area, they may stay in the original school or apply for a transfer. A transfer will be successful only when a place becomes available. Until then, the student will attend the original school, which may or may not have a bus route to the new address. 

At other international and private schools, no such restriction exists.

Top Image sourced via Shutterstock

Join the conversation

One thought on “International School or ESF? Sassy Mama Ruth Benny answers reader questions

  1. Hi, originally I planned to apply to Hillside ESF kindergarten for my daughter this year (born in December 2013) as we are living on HK Island. She started attending playgroup at Hillside in July 2015. However, we have to move by end of 2015. I wonder if it is good to apply to Tung Chung ESF since Hillside has a very long wait list whereas Tung Chung ESF is new. Or should I try one of the other three ESF kindies? Your advice is much appreciated as it will help me decide where to look for another apartment too. Although the catchment area system does not apply to kindergartens, we still can only apply to one and now that we have to move, I intend to look for a place which will be longer term taking primary school and secondary school into account as well. Thanks in advance for your help.

Comments are closed.

more sassy mama

What's New

We're social
🍳 Are your children leaving for university this year? Send them off with *Midweek Meals: Three Staple Recipes Teenagers Can Master*. Recipes by @munchkins852 on #sassymamahk now.

#midweekmeals 


Thinking of starting your own business? Make sure you read *Starting A New Business In The 852 Just Got Easier For Mumtrepreneurs* on #sassymamahk.

#mondaymotivation #mumtrepreneurs #hkbusiness

📷@byrawpixel
To all the awesome dads in the world, we salute you! Wishing you a very happy Father’s Day from all the Sassy Mamas 💙.⠀
⠀
#happyfathersday2019
Ahead of Father's Day check out #thatpapa *Eddie McDougall, Founder Of The Flying Winemaker (@theflyingwinemaker)*, one of the city’s most dynamic young papas.⠀
⠀
Go to #sassymamahk now to read Eddie's story and learn how a chance taste of wine from a discarded bottle led this papa to build a successful business and a beautiful family in Hong Kong.⠀
⠀
📷@veronicasanchis⠀
⠀
#fathersday2019 #ThatPapa⠀
⠀
Heading into the weekend like 🌈🍦. ⠀
⠀
#sassymamalove the rainbow hues of this little one.⠀
📷@wendology via our sisters @sassymamasg.⠀
⠀
#sosassy #sassymamahk #friyay
Is it just us or is this drink getting prettier by the second? *Mama’s Night Out June: New Drinks To Try This Summer* is up on #sassymamahk.⠀
⠀
📷 Sugar @easthk ⠀
⠀
#sasassy #mamasnightout #hongkongdrinks
Globe-trotting mama Nealy Fischer AKA @theflexiblechef creates recipes that are all about ditching perfection and going for flexibility. Head to our Eat channel for three delicious, fuss-free meals for the whole family to enjoy. ⠀
⠀
#sosassy #sassymamahk #FoodYouWant

We're social

What we're up to and what inspires us